Independent home guides Honest picks — no paid rankings Guides updated regularly
smhomehubHome · Kitchen · Garden
Cookware

Best Cast Iron Skillets: Budget, Mid-Range and Premium Picks

The cast iron skillets worth buying — a budget workhorse, a smaller everyday pan and an enameled premium pick, all sold on Amazon US and Australia.

We earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

Black cast iron skillet heating over an open flame

The short answer

The best cast iron skillet for most people is the Lodge 12-inch: it's cheap, made in the USA, sears beautifully and will outlive you. Buy the Lodge 10.25-inch if you cook for one or two or find heavy pans hard to lift. If you don't want to season or worry about rust, the Le Creuset Signature enameled skillet is the premium choice — at roughly ten times the price.

  • An expensive skillet doesn't cook much better than a Lodge; you pay for a smoother surface, lighter weight and looks.
  • 12 inches (30 cm) suits a family; 10 inches (26 cm) suits one or two people.
  • Bare cast iron needs drying and a thin coat of oil after washing. Enameled cast iron doesn't.
  • All three picks are sold on Amazon US and Amazon Australia under the same model.

A cast iron skillet is one of the few kitchen buys you make once. It sears steak better than anything else, goes from stove to oven to campfire, and can last generations. You also don’t need to spend much. Across independent kitchen tests, the cheapest pans keep finishing at or near the top.

Here are three skillets worth buying, from a budget workhorse to an enameled pan that never needs seasoning. All three are sold on Amazon US and Amazon Australia.

Our picks at a glance

FeatureBest overallLodge 12-inch pre-seasoned cast iron skilletBest for small householdsLodge 10.25-inch pre-seasoned cast iron skilletPremium pickLe Creuset Signature Enameled Cast Iron Skillet, 11.75 in (30 cm)
Best forSearing, roasting, cornbread, campfire cookingOne or two people, eggs, cornbread, a first cast iron panCooks who want cast iron's heat without seasoning or rust
Price bandBudgetBudgetPremium
Size12 in / 30 cm10.25 in / 26 cm11.75 in / 30 cm
WeightAbout 3.6 kg / 8 lbAbout 2.3 kg / 5 lbAbout 3 kg / 6.8 lb
FinishPre-seasoned bare ironPre-seasoned bare ironEnameled
Made inUSAUSAFrance
Where to buyCheck priceCheck priceCheck price

Best overall: Lodge 12-inch cast iron skillet

Lodge has made cast iron in Tennessee since 1896, and its plain 12-inch skillet is still the pan to beat. It comes pre-seasoned, so you can cook on it straight away. It’s heavy enough to hold its heat when a cold steak hits the pan, and big enough for a family breakfast or two steaks side by side. It also usually costs less than a takeaway dinner.

Owners agree about the downsides. It weighs about 3.6 kg (8 lb), the handle gets very hot, and the cooking surface is noticeably rough until a few months of cooking build up the seasoning. Use an oven mitt or handle cover, and cook fatty foods (bacon, burgers, shallow-fried potatoes) for the first few weeks to speed up the seasoning.

Best for small households: Lodge 10.25-inch skillet

This is the same pan as the 12-inch, just smaller and about 1.3 kg lighter. It’s the most popular cast iron skillet on Amazon. If you cook for one or two, have a small burner, or find heavy pans hard to lift, it’s the better first skillet. It handles eggs, a single steak, cornbread, a frittata or a small pan pizza. Its main limit is space: crowd it and food steams instead of searing.

Best premium pick: Le Creuset Signature enameled skillet

Enameled cast iron gives you most of cast iron’s heat with almost none of the upkeep. There’s no seasoning to build and nothing to rust. You can simmer a tomato sauce or deglaze with wine without stripping anything, and it cleans up like any other pan. Le Creuset’s version adds two pour spouts, a helper handle, a lifetime warranty and a wide range of colors.

The trade-offs are price and care. It costs roughly ten times as much as a Lodge. The enamel can chip if you drop it or bang it on a hard edge, and eggs stick more than they do on well-seasoned bare iron.

Other skillets worth knowing about

  • Victoria (Colombia): a cheap bare-iron skillet with a longer, more comfortable handle. Several testers rate it alongside Lodge. We couldn’t find it on Amazon Australia, so it isn’t one of our picks.
  • Smithey, Field Company, Stargazer: premium bare-iron skillets with polished, smoother surfaces and lighter weight. They’re lovely to cook on but cost five to eight times as much as a Lodge. They’re mostly sold direct rather than through Amazon Australia.

How to choose a cast iron skillet

Size

Size Serves Good for
8 in / 20 cm 1 Eggs, small sides, single desserts
10 in / 26 cm 1–2 Everyday cooking, one steak, cornbread
12 in / 30 cm 3–4 Family meals, two steaks, roasting chicken pieces
15 in / 38 cm 5+ Crowds and camping, but very heavy

If you’re only buying one, choose 10 or 12 inches based on how many people you cook for.

Bare vs enameled

  • Bare cast iron: cheapest, toughest, gets more non-stick over time, but needs drying and oiling after washing.
  • Enameled cast iron: no seasoning, no rust, fine with acidic foods, but expensive and can chip.

Weight and handles

A 12-inch bare skillet weighs 3–4 kg. If lifting is an issue, look for a helper handle on the opposite side (all three of our picks have one), or choose the 10-inch.

Your stovetop

Cast iron works on gas, electric, induction, in the oven and over a campfire. On glass-top cooktops, lift instead of sliding, and heat gradually on induction to avoid hot spots.

How to look after bare cast iron

  1. Clean while it’s warm. Use hot water, a brush or scraper, and a drop of soap if needed. Don’t soak it.
  2. Dry it completely. Towel it off, then warm it on the stove for a minute.
  3. Oil lightly. Wipe on a very thin layer of neutral oil and buff it until it looks almost dry.
  4. Fix rust easily. Scrub off any rust, rinse, dry, oil and heat. The pan isn’t ruined.

Still deciding between materials? Read our comparison of cast iron vs. carbon steel vs. nonstick.

Buying in Australia?

All three picks are listed on amazon.com.au with the same model numbers. Lodge and Le Creuset are also widely sold by Australian kitchen stores, so compare prices before you buy. Sizes on Australian listings are often given in centimeters: 26 cm ≈ 10.25 in and 30 cm ≈ 12 in.

The bottom line

Buy the Lodge 12-inch unless you have a reason not to. Choose the Lodge 10.25-inch for small households or lighter lifting, and the Le Creuset if you’d rather pay more than ever season a pan. Whichever you choose, cook with it often. Cast iron gets better the more you use it.

Common questions

Is Lodge cast iron good quality?

Yes. Lodge has made cast iron in South Pittsburg, Tennessee since 1896, and its standard skillets regularly top independent tests despite their low price. The surface is rougher than premium brands, but it gets smoother as the seasoning builds up.

Is an expensive cast iron skillet worth it?

Usually not for performance. Premium bare-iron skillets like Smithey have a polished, smoother surface and are nicer to hold, but they cook much like a Lodge. Pay more if you value looks and a slicker surface from day one, or choose enameled cast iron if you want to skip seasoning.

What size cast iron skillet should I buy first?

A 12-inch (30 cm) skillet if you cook for three or more or want to sear two steaks at once. A 10-inch (26 cm) skillet if you cook for one or two, have a small stove, or find heavy pans hard to lift.

Can I use a cast iron skillet on an induction or glass-top stove?

Yes. Cast iron is magnetic, so it works on induction. On glass and ceramic cooktops, lift the pan rather than sliding it, because the rough base can scratch the glass.

Can I wash cast iron with soap?

Yes, a little dish soap is fine. What damages bare cast iron is soaking it or leaving it wet. Wash, dry it straight away, warm it on the stove for a minute, and wipe on a thin layer of oil.

What's the difference between cast iron and enameled cast iron?

Bare cast iron has a seasoning layer of baked-on oil that you maintain. Enameled cast iron is coated in a glass-like enamel, so it doesn't rust, needs no seasoning, and handles acidic foods. It costs much more and can chip if banged.

Sources

Mohsin, founder and editor

Mohsin founded smhomehub to cut through the noise of product listings and give straight answers to everyday home, kitchen and garden questions. He edits every guide on the site.

Our picks come from comparing independent kitchen tests, manufacturer specifications and patterns across tens of thousands of Amazon owner reviews. We checked every pick is sold on both amazon.com and amazon.com.au. We haven't tested these skillets side by side ourselves yet. How we choose products.